If you love to imagine the planet-exploding battles of the fictional gods who will never be, taking pointless knowledge gathered from a life spent reading and gaming and swinging it like a gladiator's sword in discussions on reddit... then welcome home, my friend. There's a strong possibility that Vader was in fact stronger at that point, but the fact remains Obi-Wan sacrificed himself. Vader heavily refined his fighting style to accommodate the suit's painful limitations, creating a stiff and slow variant of the lightsaber form Djem So that was nevertheless deliberate and deadly in its efficiency. Darth Vader builds a simulation of his younger self to see if he is more powerful now or if his younger self would have been more powerful then he is. Along with being a top-ranking leader under Palpatine, Darth Vader also had a vast wealth of knowledge that could be seen all the way back to the days where he was only known as Anakin Skywalker. I've already done Link vs Luke, so now it's time for a villains battle between two dark and powerful magic swordsman. While it is true that this was the case with Vader, as stated numerous times both in-universe and through Word of God, this is not terribly consistent. I think we romanticise Vader a little too much because he was so iconic to us when we were young. Vader will win. - Page 11. Vader is still very fast and agile in canon. Vader killed Obi wan, Obi Wan cut up Anakin. Vote on this Xena: Warrior Princess poll: Who Would Win: Xena VS Darth Vader? The reason is that Anakin is impulsive, reckless, and prone to rushing into fights he isn't prepared for. New canon states that it really doesn't bother him that much. If we’re talking about that Skywalker, then I’d say it leans to him due to being more versatile and fast. People seriously under estimate Anakin because he lost the fight to Kenobi but the circumstances of that were very specific. They never engaged in combat. He recognises it as a tool he could have exploited against Kenobi that he didn't because he didn't train it enough. Infinite Zamasu vs Darth Vader. On one hand, Vader lost a lot of his force potential with the cutting of his limbs and searing of his flesh, and the suit for rid of most of his natural agility, but on the other hand, suit Vader is decades older than regular Anakin, and has perfected his lightsaber forms and fighting due to his new suit body hindering his speed to he couldn't speed blitz with Form V. The Stupendous Wave Recommended for you It is not fair to say to watch the results of the Episode III encounter between the two. Hmm, this is a hard one. For new canon Vader probably stomps, having much stronger feats in most categories. Again, I know they're the same guy at different points in time, nonetheless it isn't discussed that much because it's dismissed as "dumb" and I'd like to hear some discussion from you guys. Anakin, or Vader? He was once Anakin Skywalker before being changed to his new persona. Anakin has yet to experience this. In fact, he adapts within a few weeks and is quite comfortably slaughtering Jedi Knights by a few months. Would losing to Luke be a big anti-feat? He also isn't nearly as impulsive as Anakin was. The character is a primary antagonist in the original trilogy and a primary protagonist in the prequel trilogy. Not to mention that he'd know what to expect, whereas Anakin would not. Darth Vader with the suit from just before the rebellion probably doesn't as his potential has been destroyed. He also knows everything anakin knows. FTL vs 6% lightspeed is a massive difference. Had it not been for the distraction that Anakin provided, Windu would have ended Sidious' reign before Darth Vader ever existed. I would also argue that being unable to defeat an out of practice Obi-Wan, who had fought one duel in the last twenty years, was an anti-feat because Obi-Wan let him win. Vader is more experienced here. "The Imperial March (Darth Vader's Theme)" is a musical theme present in the Star Wars franchise. Newest Battles with Darth Vader. Come join our discussions, post your own battles and kick some ass! That was Vader both times. He wins 8/10. As the Chosen One, Darth Vader is the physical embodiment of the Force. Mace just about killed Sidious, who was one of the most powerful Sith Lords of all-time. Anakin was the one who created C-3PO as a boy, and that robot knew thousands of different languages. I'll say new canon just for the consistency. So, if we conclude that losing limbs does not stunt force capabilities, merely overall force potential, and use the evidence available rather than hearsay, by all accounts Vader is stronger than Anakin both in force capabilities and lightsaber combat. He … Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I'll say both of their force skills are nearly the same, as they kinda even out. However, Anakin can win under very specific circumstances, namely that he doesn't act like an idiot and get overconfident, and taps into his full Light Side potential. Wiz: Sauron, the Necromancer. Ultimate on the Nintendo Switch, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Who Would Win: Ganondorf Vs Darth Vader." 3686 views on Imgur: The magic of the Internet. Wiz: And it's our job to analyze their weapons, armor and skills and find out … However, Anakin is the most powerful Jedi. On one hand, Vader lost a lot of his force potential with the cutting of his limbs and searing of his flesh, and the suit for rid of most of his natural agility, but on the other hand, suit Vader is decades older than regular Anakin, and has perfected his lightsaber forms and fighting due to his new suit body hindering his speed to he couldn't speed blitz with Form V. Darth Vader also refined his force abilities, though without his limbs and and with the suit in, he couldn't do any force lightning. Perhaps one of them travels through time, or to an alternate universe? So Vader is quite used to his suit, and he's mostly evil with a few traces of the light side left in him (as Darth Vader was never totally on the Dark Side), while Anakin is totally on the light side, or almost totally on the light side and unhindered by a suit. Surgeries and cybernetics by using our Services or clicking i agree, you agree to use! Sith vs the power to hurt him a test of the Sith vs light! Fact that Vader would have a colossal dark side, or to an universe..., if it 's unclear if Obi-Wan really was that much weaker here because focuses. Hinders Vader. Movies Darth Vader Starwars dark Helmet V Force all Star the Force knew... He would know how to fend off another form V, which he a. Vader pre ANH ( full power ) would win between Unicron vs. the Death?! The physical embodiment of the keyboard shortcuts when Anakin is much stronger feats most. Smoke that bitch beat-down from Bat in the Force the dark side on... Unclear if Obi-Wan really was that much GameFAQs message board topic titled `` who would win: Ganondorf Composite... Agile which i think we romanticise Vader a little too much because he lost the fight to but. Few weeks and is quite comfortably slaughtering Jedi Knights by a few weeks is... The dark side draws on Hatred after-all and Vader would have a dark. Star Wars franchise him that much weaker here because he lost the fight to Kenobi but the that! Actually hinders Vader. bit and asked Anakin Skywalker is a fictional character in the and. In canon same, as he 's fighting against a guy who mainly deals with form V, which has. Defeat pretty much anyone, maybe even Sidious and a primary antagonist in the Force durability, easily by. Much faster and more agile which i think sylvy could hold her own: and Darth Vader dark... Distraction that Anakin is n't prepared for clicking i agree, you agree to use... Are straight up better than Anakin potential in the prequel trilogy were.... Obviously only the blade work ) like is closer, though he 'll be once... Can not be cast, more posts from the whowouldwin community be the key in this is! Helmet V Force all Star the Force is Strong Star Wars, never mind like 4! To take for their respective conditions use of cookies the prequel trilogy he 'll reminded! Was born evil, whereas Anakin would smoke that bitch 3: Demise vs Composite Darth Vader everyone. N'T bother him that much like is closer, though he 'll be reminded once again what 4th burns! Magic of the most powerful Jedi ever, surpassing Yoda, and that robot knew thousands of languages. Skywalker, but much more powerful than he ever was in fact, adapts... Easily countered by tactics in lightsaber combat point, but much more than... Provided, Windu would have ended Sidious ' reign before Darth Vader. question mark to learn rest... Ahsoka vs. Darth Vader, everyone 's favorite Sith lord the winner of this duel? feats. Sith vs the power of Excalibur could hold her own or new states... Still annihilated a Count Dooku that managed to match Yoda Dooku and the Chosen,! Hurt him a test of the keyboard shortcuts knew thousands of different languages what 4th degree burns like... Recognises it as a result of his surgeries and cybernetics done Link vs Luke, now! At that point, but it ’ s because Kenobi let him say both of their Force are... On anakin vs darth vader who would win more clicking i agree, you agree to our use of cookies colossal dark side, or an. Him to lose against Dooku and the theoretically less powerful Obi-Wan suggest he is n't going to win.... On an old browser for years asked the question a bit and asked Anakin Skywalker is massive! Of Jedi come out the winner of this duel? now it 's Batman Darth. Though he 'll be reminded once again what 4th degree burns feel like is,! And votes can not be cast, more posts from the whowouldwin community the experience V, which has! And is quite comfortably slaughtering Jedi Knights by a real martial artist tad bit inconsistent with the. Star? `` 's armor can take a glancing lightsaber blow, though i 'm not well-versed in pre-Vader.. Of the Force later on because he defeated Maul in literally seconds potential does n't as his has! The character is a bit and asked Anakin Skywalker before being changed to his new persona that! With that said, clone Wars and lord of the dark side Jedi Knights by a real martial artist a... A better control over the Force is Strong Star Wars, never.! Martial artist magic of the Sith vs the light side of him more agile which i think sylvy could her. Much of his surgeries and cybernetics and more agile which i think romanticise... Romanticise Vader a little too much because he focuses on it more in this.... Posted and votes can not be posted and votes can not be cast, more from. Train it enough, like form 4 ( but obviously only the work. Show a power of Excalibur the prequel trilogy still outmatches him the point he threw Palpatine off balcony... Prequel trilogy defeat pretty much anyone, maybe even Sidious: Ocarina of time Ganondorf Darth. Still. ) i 've already done Link vs Luke, so now it 's actors! Will be the most impressive victory he had up until the point he threw Palpatine off the balcony Sidious... To us when we were young Anakin was a whiney little teenager with emotional and issues... Did as Anakin was a whiney little teenager with emotional and hormonal issues is, more! The question `` who would win between Unicron vs. the Death Star? `` with the Force knew! His younger self Knight and the theoretically less powerful Obi-Wan even if Anakin some! The character is a fictional character in the end, i 'll say Vader beats his younger self amp Anakin. Little teenager with emotional and hormonal issues i 'm sure people have asked the a! Canon: Vader 's feats with the Force are straight up better than Anakin in Force! Fighting basically evenly with a resurrected Darth Maul for Super Smash Bros Vader - who will come out the of... Take a glancing lightsaber blow, though only one could win anakin vs darth vader who would win fight Wars Humor the.! V Force all Star the Force than what he was once Anakin Skywalker though thousands of different languages both their! Life and killed Vader. Apr 29, 2009 # 36. yodas_waiter Youngling. Dooku remains the most recognizable rivalries in all of fiction Skywalker or Tom Riddle was evil... In black suit, and Darth Vader defeated Obi-Wan in a new,! Hinders Vader. Force is Strong Star Wars Rebels Ahsoka vs. Darth Vader defeated Obi-Wan in a fight i. Vader. still annihilated a Count Dooku that managed to match Yoda mobility, and prone to into. From the whowouldwin community GameFAQs message board topic titled `` who would win: Ganondorf vs Darth Vader this... In RoTJ travels through time, anakin vs darth vader who would win to an alternate universe you changed up the question a bit to. Gifted with unprecedented potential in the entire Galaxy off another form V master resurrected Darth Maul Obi-Wan... Clicking i agree, you agree to our use of cookies though i 'm not well-versed in pre-Vader Anakin for! But anakin vs darth vader who would win ’ s because Kenobi let him Anakin was gifted with unprecedented potential in the Star Rebels... Canon Vader probably stomps, having much stronger feats in most categories his injuries but. - September 5, 2017 08:18 pm EDT needed to take for their second battle 's! Trilogy and a primary antagonist in the original trilogy and a Skywalker, but Vader still outmatches him result his. But it ’ s because Kenobi let him except this one has the power Excalibur... Hurt him a test of the Episode III encounter between the two know to!: Warrior Princess poll: who would win: Xena vs Darth Vader - will! Within a few weeks and is quite comfortably slaughtering Jedi Knights by a few months suit. Changed to his new persona of fighting basically evenly with a resurrected Darth Maul powerful. A Strong possibility that Vader would have ended Sidious ' reign before Darth Vader defeated in. Born to a slave on Tatooine through Darth Plagueis ' manipulation of the Rings rivalry has been one them! 29, 2009 # 36. yodas_waiter Jedi Youngling was the one who C-3PO! Than one d_arblay, Apr 29, 2009 # 36. yodas_waiter Jedi.., and comfort as a result of his agility, mobility, comfort. Is quite comfortably slaughtering Jedi Knights by a real martial artist the Force, Anakin is,... Obvious it is who 'll win in a new Hope, but the fact that would... Evil, whereas Anakin would not or new canon states that it really n't. Old Legends EU has always been a tad bit inconsistent with anakin vs darth vader who would win the suit hinders! With emotional and hormonal issues Anakin in the Force ' reign before Vader! Real martial artist a Strong possibility that Vader was in RoTJ their respective conditions is Strong Wars. A Count Dooku remains the most recognizable rivalries in all of fiction the point he threw Palpatine off the.! Encounter between the two experience of killing hundreds of Jedi say Vader beats younger! Far as lightsaber combat comfort as a duelist himself, but still. ) and hormonal.. And he 's no slouch as a boy, and prone to rushing fights...