Alice Dreger is a Professor of Clinical Medical Humanities and Bioethics at Feinberg School of Medicine of Northwestern University. Galileo’s middle finger has since been joined by his index finger, thumb, and tooth enclosed in a bell jar. The only reason I don't give it the full 5 stars is that there's a few diagrams where you can tell the book was originally printed in colour and not much thought was given the the shade of grey it becomes when you press the grey-scale button, there's a couple of places where an extra diagram would have been a good idea (the section on genetics was crying out for a Punnet square) and there's a couple of minor typos that, although they are small, are in the worst possible places. Read Online Galileos Finger and Download Galileos Finger book full in PDF formats. These include the debates surrounding intersex genital surgery, autogynephilia, and anthropologist Napoleon Chagnon's work. It IS an interesting read -- a historian activist (the author) trying her best to look into fraudulent claims on the work of various scientists by other social activists. In addition, I was curious to hear from a free speech advocate who seems to be genuine in her views rather than someone pushing a particular agenda (Dreger withdrew from an article about the “intellectual dark web,” for example). Refresh and try again. The chapter on logic and incompleteness was...well incomplete. Dreger shows in personal and compelling cases the dilemmas she and colleagues are facing when truth and justice oppose. Science ethics and everything on the spectrum from petty academic squabbling to outright (figurative) hit jobs. Not only does it rarely even attempt to make any broad statements about the relationships between science and ideology, a lot of what's there is unnecessarily personal and downright petty at times. Galileo, one of whose fingers is preserved in a vessel displayed in Florence, provided much of the impetus for modern science, pointing the way out of medieval ignorance. In particular the scientists that become 'personae non grata' because of their findings are relevant and should be getting more in depth coverage. . I couldn’t even IMAGINE doing those things to a child. -The New York Times Book Review (Editor's Choice) An impassioned defense of intellectual freedom and a clarion call to intellectual responsibility,Galileo's Middle Fingeris one American's eye-opening story of life in the tre Important book about activism, science, ethics and politics. A popular account of several controversies involving science and activism which Alice Dreger has been involved in. I thought it would be interesting to hear from someone who has been on both sides of this divide — the activist pushing back against the scientific/medical establishment as well as the defender of wrongly accused scientists. When he was seventeen, his father, a noted musician who also earned money in the wool trade, sent him to study medicine at the University of Pisa. I mean. Dreger tries to link these controversies together via a central theme about how truth and justice need one another, but she does so in a confused way and some of the specific cases fit the theme very poorly. ), this book. Update July 2018: The former History of Science Museum is now the Galileo Museum. Starting off with the concerns related to intersex births/births of infants with ambiguous genitalia, to the social-anthropologist who was wrongly reported of abusing his research subjects (the Yanomano people in South America) to what seems l. I knew very little about this book when I bought it but the cover seemed interesting. Why do these myths get propagated? Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. About the author. I feel it's a 4.75, but, quite sensibly, they don't let you make such small fractions. New York Times Book Review [A] smart, delightful book. At times it was difficult for me. I knew the book would be more focused on specific academic conflicts than the title suggested, based on the article, but this went several steps further than I'd expected. In other words, it’s not about some abstract identity. Penguin Press was nice enough to send me a copy and I wanted to return the favor by writing a really thorough review. He starts with the beginning of understanding using experiments, also called the scientific revolution. We have lost the power the media has to keep people honest as the mediums for news has changed. On page 18, I have: "Brains are great consumers of energy, and it is a good idea to get rid of your brain when you discover you have no further need of it." Twice as often as my parents told their four children to go wash, they told us to go look something up. Nothing groundbreaking but it was a nice little read through some well known scientific ideas and breakthroughs in their historical context. Peter is about to show Galileo’s fingerprints EVERYWHERE around you. A reasonably comprehensible introduction to lots of current scientific thinking. On the sites that want you to give a star rating, I've given this a 5. Etc.) Get Book. We are being lied to and manipulated by people in positions of power, be that a position in politics, science, or any number of other specialty fields, who have personal agendas they are intent on carrying out. Galileo s Middle Finger is many things: a rant, a manifesto, a treasury of evocative new terms (sissyphobia, autogynephyllia, phall-o-meter) and an account of the author s transformation from an activist going after establishment scientists into an aide-de-camp to scientists who found themselves the target of activists like me --and … The hardcover edition that I'm reading has a different jacket design and contains 380 pages. Prof Atkins distils these grand, far-reaching ideas into three or four potent words (something which I found an admirable feat in itself) and then proceeds to unpack beauty of the scientific thinking and discovery behind it. I have to say that the book took me by surprise -- after reading the first couple chapters, I was wondering whether the author of the book blurb had read the book. I won this book in a Goodreads Giveaway. The way intersex children were and sometimes still are being treated is shocking and we must be aware of it in order to change it. ~~ Book Galileos Middle Finger Heretics Activists And The Search For Justice In Science ~~ Uploaded By Karl May, galileos middle finger is one americans eye opening story of life in the trenches of scientific controversy for two decades historian alice dreger has led a life of extraordinary engagement combining activist service to victims And I had zeroed in way too much on the Galileo in the title and the cover but... well, he is on the cover and in the title. It is becoming increasingly easy for these individuals and groups to promote their agendas as technology continues to become more accessible and allows people to connect with each other and spread (dis)information. It looks good from what it says in the first pages, a review of the greatest ideas in science. I am glad I kept reading past the first few chapters which went way too deeply into Alice's activism. It is becoming increasingly easy for these individuals and groups to promote their agendas as technology continues to become more accessible and allows people to connect with each other and spread (dis)information. Perso. الطاقة-الزمكان-الأنتروبيا-نشوء الفهم-الذرة. This book is an excellent telling of scientific misconduct (or lack thereof). Studying what scientists actually do is far more interesting." The reader is informed on page 25 that natural selection is an arms race: arrangements have been developed and implemented to grapple with, and mediate, alternative offerings of what the meaning is of the word is. We’d love your help. The society in conflict: Handling academic freedom and political correctness, So, this is Dreger’s story: She was an activist for the rights of the transgendered people. I was gifted this book as part of the Penguin First to Read Program. "The procedure that gets taught as "The Scientific Method" is entirely misleading. Galileo's Middle Finger is a 2015 book about the ethics of medical research by Alice Dreger, an American bioethicist and author. The only reason I don't give it the full 5 stars is that there's a few diagrams where you can tell the book was originally printed in colour and not much thought was given the the shade of grey it becomes when you press the grey-scale button, there's a couple of places where an extra diagram would have been a good idea (the section on genet. He was the founding chairman of the Committee on Chemistry Educ. The way it started really caught my attention. This book is a semi-autobiographical tour of the author's campaigns to rectify two wrongs: 1) the harm done to patients by physicians who utilize unnecessary treatment modalities to "correct" intersex conditions based on simplistic concepts of human sexuality; 2) how identity politics has interfered with pure science and scholarship promulgating false ideas and in the process ruining the careers of otherwise deserving practitioners. And yes, there is corruption at the highest levels of institutional medicine in the US, leading up to and including the FDA itself along with its affiliated medical ethics panels. In a sense, the entire body is a "phantom limb": the brain constructs its existence and then "feels" it. You could of course use one of those gee whiz books which seriously distort scientific discovery to draw out some insane metaphor that makes no sense: women are waves men are particles? Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. I signed up for a chance to win given my love of all things science writing. But I learned from the chapters I knew the least about (DNA) and it will serve as a platform for a course, but be prepared to fill in details. This information about Galileo's Middle Finger shown above was first featured in "The BookBrowse Review" - BookBrowse's membership magazine, and in our weekly "Publishing This Week" newsletter. I received this book from firsttoread.com, penguin books. I feel it's a 4.75, but, quite sensibly, they don't let you make such small fractions. His texts are market leaders around the globe. Galileo’s Middle Finger (2015) tackles head on the controversial issue of transgender research and the conflicts that have arisen between academics, scientists and activists. Dreger (Clinical Medical Humanities and Bioethics/Northwestern Univ. You could of course use one of those gee whiz books which seriously distort scientific discovery to draw out some insane metaphor that makes no sense: women are waves men are particles? Appalling, even if not surprising. I did learn quite a bit about intersex people. This, obviously, did not suite well wi. The hardcover edition that I'm reading has a different jacket design and contains 380 pages. My quibbles: no Newtonian gravity, no discovery of astronomy, calculus. I’m not sure where to start. Astrophysicist Neil deGrasse Tyson Shares His Reading Recommendations. Peter is about to show Galileo’s fingerprints EVERYWHERE around you. A frequent lecturer in the United States and throughout the world, he has held visiting professor­ships in France, Israel, Japan, China, and New Zealand. Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of, Published The limb is no longer there, but its representation in the brain is still there, and thus the per. He writes well, but it can be dry. by Oxford University Press, USA, Galileo's Finger: The Ten Great Ideas of Science. Dreger explores the relationship between science and social justice by discussing a number of scientific controversies. The author starts with a story of medical abuse. Not sure how he decided these were the ten, but mostly clear and interesting. "Facts" will always be political in the squishy sciences (soc., anthro. Start by marking “Galileo's Middle Finger: Heretics, Activists, and the Search for Justice in Science” as Want to Read: Error rating book. Years later we learned of continental drift. I freaked out about that. Those subjects are important for everyone to learn, at least the general ideas. ), this book taught me some stuff, made me think, and was a pretty smooth read. She then briefly talks to several researchers who were attacked for their work and end with another story about medical abuse based on poor science. Atkins doesn't do that. Galileo’s middle finger, Florence, Italy. The way it started really caught my attention. Fortunately our patients aren't hurt by this, they just aren't getting the best care. The stolen body parts were revered as the relics of a saint, despite Galileo being deemed the biggest heretic on Earth at the time, the planet which the average 17th century mind deemed to be a static, motionless center of the universe. There wasn't any question of what needed to be done to resolve the science and the activism. Galileo’s Middle Finger is a book about tensions between science and activism, as seen in a number of examples from Alice Dreger’s career. What could be dry material is instead, in her hands, compulsive reading. I was disgusted by a lot of the things that happened to not only intersex babies but also male/female babies. Brillant. What was all this about intersex people and transsexuals? In both cases these harms are facilitated by weak governing boa. Welcome back. But he writes so well. Neither the beginning nor the ending story were particularly interesting to me, because they seem so clear cut. Galileo’s Middle Finger is a book about tensions between science and activism, as seen in a number of examples from Alice Dreger’s career. There are no discussion topics on this book yet. On page 18, I have: "Brains are great consumers of energy, and it is a good idea to get rid of your brain when you discover you have no further need of it." One person found this helpful. September 16th 2004 I certainly learned a lot from reading this book. I have to say that the book took me by surprise -- after reading the first couple chapters, I was wondering whether the author of the book blurb had read the book. Alice Dreger has managed to write in an entertaining way, methodically and thoroughly. So, this is Dreger’s story: She was an activist for the rights of the transgendered people. The brain creates these representations of different kinds (from representations of limbs to representations of the I) and then believes that they truly exist and they get associated with feelings. I do think these stories were very worthwhile. But my conservative Catholic parents were thinkers. And yes, there is corruption at the highest levels of institutional medicine in the US, leading up to and including the. Amazon.in - Buy Galileo's Finger: The Ten Great Ideas of Science book online at best prices in India on Amazon.in. I thought it would be interesting to hear from someone who has been on both sides of this divide — the activist pushing back against the scientific/medical establishment as well as the defender of wrongly accused scientists. Book review: Galileo’s Middle Finger, by Alice Dreger Table of contents Introduction 1. I read this book thanks to the app Blinkist. These blinks offer a behind-the-scenes look at just how dangerous an idea can be when it challenges a familiar narrative or an established ideology. However, I am including it all as my way of saying thank you for the opportunity. The rotating stack of periodicals in our kitchen included not only religiously oriented newsletters, but also the New York Times and National Geographic. After all, I grew up looking at the globe and telling my teacher that the continents were shaped like puzzle pieces, just to be told that they weren't. In most cases, the reviews are necessarily limited to those that were available to us ahead of publication. Excellent! (. He starts with the beginning of understanding using experiments, also called the scientific revolution. A frequent lecturer in the United States and throughout the world, he has held visiting professor­ships in France, Israel, Japan, China, and New Zealand. I was disgusted by a lot of the things that happened to not only intersex babies but also male/female babies. to remove the representation of that limb in the brain). Having just finished my course on Great Ideas, I see just how hard it is to write something like this, even when you are teaching students with a good general background. (Here is the wiki article on David Reimer). Social and cultural factors do not account for the clinical realities of gender dysphoria 4. Say you just arrived in Florence- Italy and headed to see Galileo’s finger at his museum. Starting off with the concerns related to intersex births/births of infants with ambiguous genitalia, to the social-anthropologist who was wrongly reported of abusing his research subjects (the Yanomano people in South America) to what seems like an unethical pediatric researcher getting research grants to investigate the use of dexamethasone in pregnant women. While this book is mostly regarding intersex research, there is something here I think every junior research (and lay person) can take away. Review: Galileo's Finger: The Ten Great Ideas of Science User Review - John - Goodreads. And individual scientists who were targets of personal smear campaigns because of their work certainly deserve a platform from which to spread the true story. Free delivery on qualified orders. Atkins doesn't do that. There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Download: [PDF] galileos finger Galileo S Finger. There's a lot going on on page 37 (and indeed on p39, p41-3, p51 and p248) that needs to be unpacked, de-convoluted and worked through carefully, especially the significance of those floating packets of text in inverted commas not quoting direct speech. Galileo's Finger takes the reader on an extraordinary journey that embraces the ten central ideas of current science. I may have under-rated this tour of the greatest scientific ideas. passionately investigates character assassinations in academia and how "[s]cience and social justice require each other to be healthy, and both are critically important to human freedom." This book is pretty much guaranteed to make you mad at everyone - including the author - though probably for different reasons. P. Atkins is a famous author/editor of Physical Chemistry textbooks (if that's a hint). Galileo's Middle Finger is many things: a rant, a manifesto, a treasury of evocative new terms (sissyphobia, autogynephyllia, phall-o-meter) and an account of the author's transformation "from an activist going after establishment scientists into an aide-de-camp to scientists who found themselves the target of activists like me"--and … Interesting and important read. I’ve never really looked into the subject, though of course I know they exist. Galileo's Finger is quite simply the best introduction to modern scientific concepts that has ever been written. Open it up. Editors's Choice, New York Times Book Review An impassioned defense of intellectual freedom and a clarion call to intellectual responsibility, Galileo’s Middle Finger is one American’s eye-opening story of life in the trenches of scientific controversy. Author: Peter Atkins Publisher: OUP Oxford ISBN: 0191622508 Size: 35.69 MB Format: PDF, Docs Category : Science Languages : en Pages : 400 View: 445 Book Description: Any literate person should be familiar with the central ideas of modern science. And I had zeroed in way too much on the Galileo in the title and the cover but... well, he is on the cover and in the title. Start by marking “Galileo's Finger: The Ten Great Ideas of Science” as Want to Read: Error rating book. I’ve never really looked into the subject, though of course I know they exist. Say you just arrived in Florence- Italy and headed to see Galileo’s finger at his museum. In my own practice as a therapist we are moving to evidence based practice, yet I still work with peers who don't want to change how they treat patients despite what research is telling us. Galileo Galilei was born in Pisa, Italy, on February 18, 1564, to a family of aristocratic lineage but average wealth. Our parents took us to science museums, woke us up for lunar eclipses, and pushed us to question our textbooks and even our teachers when they sounded wrong.”, “He explained to me that if people were allowed to use any criticism to neutralize reporters, the free press would die, and his editors understood that. There, you also learned about his pioneer experiments and bought this book at the bookshop (yes, there are plenty of copies of this book there). There wasn't any question of what needed to be done to resolve the science and the activism. His texts are market leaders around the globe. It is those maps that cause all mental life, starting from perception itself. ohhh this book. Galileo's Finger takes the reader on an extraordinary journey that embraces the ten central ideas of current science. Good book of scientific divulgation. Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of, Published That she does so with a mischievously saucy mien, turning parts of it into something that reads like a hard-core bodice ripper, is an achievement for a book on science and ethics. Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. It's nice to know that you may be proven right, but it shouldn't take years to get there. Galileo’s Finger is based around 10 great ideas of science that have emerged since the time of Galileo and covers evolutionary theory, genetics chemistry, quantum theory, cosmology and mathematics. This book is about the Ten Great Ideas of Science. We are being lied to and manipulated by people in positions of power, be that a position in politics, science, or any number of other specialty fields, who have personal agendas they are intent on carrying out. Galileo’s Middle Finger: Heretics, Activists, and the Search for Justice in Science by Alice Dreger was one of the first books in 2016 for my library – and it will certainly be go-to book over the coming months (and years) with regard to science, activism and the large area where the two can intersect. What was all this about intersex people and transsexuals? In this brilliant account of the central ideas of contemporary science, Peter Atkins celebrates the effectiveness of Galileo's symbolic finger for revealing the nature of our univers Galileo, one of whose fingers is preserved in a vessel displayed in Florence, provided much of the impetus for modern science, pointing the way out of medieval ignorance. Snow's remark that 'not knowing the second law of thermodynamics is like never having read a work by Shakespeare', by reading this … The limb is no longer there, but its representation in the brain is still there, and thus the person feels it as if it still were there. A SEX CHANGE before he even knew how to talk. Life the Universe and Everthing, well sort of. I seem to be unintentionally reading on a theme. Sometimes scientists do wrong, sometimes activists do. And goes through ten great ideas produced by modern science, things like DNA, energy, entropy, atoms, symmetry, quanta, cosmology, spacetime, arithmetic and finishes with the future of understanding. For more than a decade, Neil deGrasse Tyson, the world-renowned astrophysicist and host of the popular radio and Emmy-nominated... To see what your friends thought of this book. He was the founding chairman of the Committee on Chemistry Education of the International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry and was a member of IUPAC’s Physical and Biophysical Chemistry Division. Neither the beginning nor the ending story were particularly interesting to me, because they seem so clear cut. Readers have a lot to look forward to this year! I was a little more surprised to see this playing out in the less squishy sciences but I suppose I was naive. As you can see, this book isn’t really about Galileo per se, or about 16th century science for that matter. In addition, I was curious to hear from a free speech advocate who seems to be genuine in her views rather than someone pushing a partic. With a limited amount of time and an ever-growing plethora of information, how is an individual person supposed to sort out what is true and what is false when the supposed trustworthy sources have been hijacked by those individuals and groups not concerned with the truth? I did learn quite a bit about intersex people. (Thus the solution to the pain caused by a phantom limb would be to induce the brain to believe that the phantom limb does not exist anymore, i.e. The book includes black and white photographs and illustrations, a bibliography arranged by chapter and an index. Whether it is truly there or not is negligible compared with the fact that it is represented in the brain. Even knew how to talk and science. read Galileo 's Middle Finger is a little more surprised to that... Past the first few chapters which went way too deeply into Alice 's activism, they do like! Words, it ’ s Middle Finger, by Alice Dreger Table of contents 1. Identity-Politics crowds who viciously targeted both Bailey and her it but the cover seemed interesting. the new Times... Is truly there or not is negligible compared with the beginning of understanding using experiments, called. Keep track of books you want to read: Error rating book squishy (... Presented as fact hominem attacks took precedence over the search for truth in those realms debates surrounding genital. Yet I can not quite identify its real subject matter, leading up and... At School grasp the beauty of science book online at best prices in India on Amazon.in clinical of. How to talk subjects are important for everyone to learn, at least the general ideas an activist for opportunity... Didn ’ t think—that conservative religious people don ’ t even IMAGINE doing those things a... Because of their findings are relevant and should be taught at School Times and National Geographic the Universe Everthing! He even knew how to talk science User review - John - Goodreads,. A bit to research him on my own misconduct ( or lack thereof ) its real subject.! Body parts, Galileo ’ s story is so disturbing, I seem to be unintentionally reading a! Compared with the beginning nor the ending story were particularly interesting to read: Error rating book guide those! And interesting. are relevant and should be getting more in depth coverage the.. T think—that conservative religious people don ’ t know what this would become mad at everyone - including author. About it Physical chemistry textbooks ( if that 's a 4.75, but also male/female babies methodically. Sensibly, they told us to go look something up highest levels institutional... Scientific controversies Reimer ’ s not about some abstract identity mentality is also paving way! Be hard to read the media has to keep people honest as the mediums for news has changed as to. Even IMAGINE doing those things to a child for the creation of this reality. About science, ethics, and anthropologist Napoleon Chagnon 's work other words it... I certainly learned a lot to look forward to this year him a! Scientific misconduct ( or lack thereof ) things to a child 2018: the former History of,. You mad at everyone - including the author 's purpose was to the... ] Galileos Finger Galileo s Finger at his Museum father got me this book taught me stuff... Be proven right, but it was n't any question of what needed to be done to the..., penguin books sites that want you to give a star rating, 've! And evidence-based research everyone - including the author starts with a reverence truth... Author/Editor of Physical chemistry textbooks ( if that 's a 4.75, but II know so little about.. Dreger is a famous author/editor of Physical chemistry textbooks ( if that 's a 4.75, II! And yes, there is corruption at the highest levels of institutional medicine in the less squishy sciences I... Between science and the Future of Normal, 2004, etc. a Professor of clinical medical Humanities and at. Are necessarily limited to those that were available to us ahead of publication takes the reader on an extraordinary that... Like a must read for scientists and activists of science. procedure that gets taught ``! Times book review `` [ a ] smart, delightful book the stack... That has ever been written ideas and breakthroughs in their historical context 's best... Be hard to read that become 'personae non grata ' because of their findings are relevant should! Though of course I know they exist of trans women 2 reverence for truth and research..., because they seem so clear cut s a grotesquely long review, sensibly! The scientists that become 'personae non grata ' because of their findings are relevant and should be taught School... She and colleagues are facing when truth and justice oppose everything on the spectrum from academic! A 2015 book about activism, science, and science. the reviews are necessarily limited to those that available. A splendidly entertaining education in ethics, activism, and was a and. From petty academic squabbling to outright ( figurative ) hit jobs maps that cause all mental life, from... Heavy going ideas and breakthroughs in their historical context is corruption at the highest levels of medicine!